Skip to Content

Questions on MACP

52 replies [Last post]
IRE Guest's picture
IRE Guest
Offline
Joined: 26/01/2012
Posts:
Printer-friendly version

All the questions on MACP . The forum is closed. Further questions can be posted here: http://indianrailwayemployee.com/forum/questions-macp-scheme

Guest's picture
Guest

I got appointed as traffic apprentice on 29-7-2002. Completed training and got posted as SM II on 29-7-2004. Have not received any punishment or promotion till date. When i would get first macp?

dhar's picture
dhar
Offline
Joined: 12/08/2010
Posts:

10 years from your date of posting, ie, in July 2014

Guest's picture
Chandra Mohan Singh

Sir, 

I was in grade 5200-20200 (gr payRs. 2800). Igot last  (3) MACP but they did not  change my 

pay band. Now Iam retired and my last Pay shows in my PPO as 5200-20200 (Gr.4200 ) MACPS.

Is it right ? or it should be written as 9300-43000 (GR.4200) MACPS

 

Guest's picture
S S BORALKAR

1)Appointed as sub.khalasi  in Grade Rs.196-132 (RS).in Elect Dept

and regularized on 08.02.1980.

2)Promoted as Jr.Clerk Gr.950-1500(RS) on 29.08.1983.

3)Appointment Sr.Clerk  Graduate quota (open market)  through  RRB Mumbai G Pay 2800 14.05.1987

4)Promoted as Head Clerk Grade Pay 4200( 1st promotion) 06.02.1992

5)Promoted as OS II ( Grade merged with Head Clerk) GP4200 05.07.1997

6)2nd t Financial up gradation  under MACPS GP Rs.4600 01.09.2008

as per  para No.9 of ANNEXURE of Rly  Bd’s letter No.RBE No.101/2009 dt.10.06.2009

7)Demanding 3rd   Financial up gradation under MACPS w.e.f 06.02.2012 as per Rly.Bd’s  No. RBE No.101 /2009 dated 10.06.2009

(ii) In case he does not get any promotion thereafter, then he would get 3rd financial upgradation in PB-2 in Grade Pay of Rs.4200 on completion of further 10 years of service i.e. after 28 years (8+10+10).

Whether I am eligible for  3rd   Financial up gradation under MACPS w.e.f 06.02.2012

das's picture
das
Offline
Joined: 25/12/2011
Posts:

You have completed 20 years in 4200 in feb 2012. So you are eligible for 3rd MACP.

Guest's picture
Guest

R/Sir
I was appointed as ASM on 19.02.1988 in 1200-2040 grade. I was promoted in 1400-2300 grade on October 1990.
I came own request transfer from Ratlam division to Jhansi division in July 1998 in bottom seniority and initial grade 1200-2040
I again promoted in 1400-2300 grade in Nov. 2003 in cader restructring.After completion of 23 years service i am in 4200 grade pay. 
I have not recieved MACP benefit. Please tell me when i got MACP benefit.
Madhusudan
My E mail-legendmusic193@gmail.com
                   madhusudan530@gmail.com 

ram's picture
ram
Offline
Joined: 14/11/2011
Posts:

In case of Inter-division transfer cases 1 st MACP wont be given, but you are eligible for second MACP on completion of 20 years of Railway service, that in Feb 2008.

Thanks for answer, but my division officials (Agra /NCR) not follow the rules they are telling me that you entitled in nov. 2013 for 3rd MACP.

So please give me a appropriate rule or illustration. 

Again Thanks

rokns's picture
rokns
Offline
Joined: 24/08/2011
Posts:

I join railway through rrb cdg on 10dec1990in central telephone enquiry,new delhi and start working indipendently from 19/06/1991 after passing chandusi training institute

Now what will be my date of appointment and after completing 20 years sevice from which date my 2nd MACP will due.

 

Guest's picture
subrahmanyam bommuluri

dear sir,

I have joined as Assistant Teacher(EM), through RRB in the year 1993, in the grade Rs.1200-2040. I got promotion as TGT(maths & Physical Science) in the year 

2003, Now I am in the Scale of 9300-34800 with grade pay Rs.4600. My qualification is BSc(Maths,physics &chemistry),MSc(Maths), MPhil(Maths), BEd.My age is 46years.

My problem is that , The railway high scools are on edge of clossure due to the lack of students.could you please suggest an option which protect my pay & grade pay in departments like personnel,commercial and accounts?

Am I eligible for the posts like CMA in workshops as i have BSC(Chemistri) as qualification?

Grateful for your positive reply. Thanking you sir.

 

dhar's picture
dhar
Offline
Joined: 12/08/2010
Posts:

If such a situation come, you will be surplus. You will be given an alternate post and your pay will be protected. You can give it in writing for the post you are intersted in which you have the qualification, but CPO will decide.

sl's picture
sl
Offline
Joined: 15/03/2012
Posts:

why MACP does not convey or confer promotion rights along with it ?  an employee with MACP is barred and not eligible for appearing for further promotion selection !! this is atrocious.  MACP is granted to employees who have already slogged for more than 10-12 years without promotion.  MACP only gives the next Gr. Pay and it then bars the employee from appearing for selection in the further promotional selection.  This policy should be suitably modified to accommodate the employees to give right to appear for selections for promotions.  otherwise the MACP scheme does not have any meaning. Thanks. 

das's picture
das
Offline
Joined: 25/12/2011
Posts:

MACP is meant to give only financial relief. It is financial upgradation. 

Guest's picture
anjali

sir, i am  going to join railway as senior section engineer. if i will get MACP then my pay grade will be change to 4600 to 4800.  at that time after few months of it, if i will clear my my exam and get promotion. at that time my grade pay will change or remains same.

ram's picture
ram
Offline
Joined: 14/11/2011
Posts:

Grade pay wont change. You wont have any financial benefits.

Guest's picture
Guest

Sir, I hv joined railway in grade 2550-55-3200  in 5/6/1996 . 

I was promoted in grade 2650-65-4000  in 1999

i got another promotion as ASM through GDCE quota in grade 4500-7000  in  year  2000

I got promotion in grade 5000-8000 in  year 2002

 i got  5000-8000 in 6 and half year service.

Now i wnt to know , When i would get MACP and how many due for me, Please reply me soon Sir coz in nov 2012 my ten years in 4200 will be completed.

Guest's picture
Guest

You will get it in Nov 2012

Guest's picture
jose

Promotion through GDCE will be considered as one promotion. Hence you got 3 promotions already and hence not eligible for MACP. As for GDCE if Railway Board decides in future that it will be considered like a fresh RRB recruitment it you get 46oo in nov 2012 and 4800 in another 10 years.

Guest's picture
Guest

Sir, I hv joined railway in grade 2550-55-3200  in 5/6/1996 . 
I was promoted in grade 2650-65-4000  in 1999
i got another promotion as ASM through GDCE quota in grade 4500-7000  in  year  2000
I got promotion in grade 5000-8000 in  year 2002
 i got  5000-8000 in 6 and half year service.
Now i wnt to know , When i would get MACP and how many due for me, Please reply me soon

 

Sir coz in nov 2012 my ten years in 4200 will be completed.,

 

One reply i hv received and according to that i vll get MACP in NOV .But   Some body  told me that u hv got  three promotions already so  no MACP will be given to me in future

please give me detail that how many MACP due for me , please reply

 

dhildar's picture
dhildar
Offline
Joined: 27/04/2012
Posts:

MACP Clarification

my scale of pay 9300-34800 starting  GP 4200 

Sir i have joined railways in 02.04.1983 

after completion of training i absorbed as JE  on 14.02.1985

I got promotion as Section Engineer on 28.05.1999

please give me detail that how many MACP due for me , please reply
 

jp's picture
jp
Offline
Joined: 07/02/2012
Posts:

You should be getting 4800 from Feb 2005 , ie 20 years from joining as JE.

Guest's picture
Guest

Any one got  the appointment for JE(elect/TRD) from kota division.please reply

Guest's picture
Guest

sir, 

   i want to know that where is the training centre  for JE(elect/TRD) kota div.(wcr railway).After training where  i am posted in only rajasthan or out of rajasthan also.plz reply

das's picture
das
Offline
Joined: 25/12/2011
Posts:

Institutional training will be at Centralised Electrical Training Institute, Thakurli or Indian Railway Institute of Electrical Engineering, Nasik. Job training and posting will be in Kota division only.

​See here for training details: http://indianrailwayemployee.com/content/training-module-je-and-se-electrical

Guest's picture
Anil Choudhary_123

Das, i need to discuss about the Bond issue before joining in railway. Can u give ur mail id ?

maheshparmesh's picture
maheshparmesh
Offline
Joined: 06/02/2012
Posts:

sir

i am Tech. Gr-III passed. Is that possible to get mutual in training. How many days after joining i can apply for transfer or mutual transfer? How many days time taken for this process?

pl. replay

Guest's picture
jp2

No. Railways No longer give alternate appointment to medically unfit candidates.

I am a senior clerk under SCW/SYAE/LLH in Eastern Railway  absorbed as casual labour on 01-09-1976 and decasualized as Khalasi w.e.f 24-12-1980 in Engineering dept.  On 16-05-1986 I have been  taken in to permanent vacancy of Khalasi . I thereafter promoted to Clerk Gr.11under mechanical department on 03-04-1995 and on 21-11-2005 to Clerk Gr.1 with grade payRs.2800/-

 

I had no break during availing temporary status  prior to  joining in regular appointment. Now my question is whether I am entitled to get MACP

 

 

   DATE:- 29-04-2012                                              SANAT KUMAR TA

                                                                                     Clerk Gr.1 under

                                                                                   SSE/C&W/SYAE/LLH

                                                                                     P.F. A/C No:-04587935

dhar's picture
dhar
Offline
Joined: 12/08/2010
Posts:

See this circular: http://indianrailwayemployee.com/content/macp-scheme-reckon-entire-temporary-status-service-substitutes

It says: "The entire temporary status service of substitutes followed by regularisation without break may be taken into account towards the minimum service of 10, 20 and 30 years for the purpose of grant of benefit under the MACP Scheme. "

You had break between 24-12-1980 & 16-05-1986??

There was no break in service between 24-12-1980 & 16-05-1986.

Thanks & regard

Guest's picture
sachin mehra

hello frds.......

                     any one got SE Pway joinging from RRB Ahemdabad on CEN 05/2010......

plz...... inform me on 9993795040

                                                                                                                                       Thank u

Guest's picture
V.RAMMOHANRAO

I joined as Tech-III in Tr D department in 1981and got promotions as Tech-II in1986, Tech-I in 1995 and got selected as JE-II through LDCE in 1999. It was completed more than 13years in JE grade. Am I eligible for MACP or not. Please clarify.

I came to know that the MACP for the LDCE recruitees will be at par with direct recruitees as in the ACP scheme of Vth CPC, irrespective of their previous promotions and length of service rendered in previous grades. Is it true ?

 

jp's picture
jp
Offline
Joined: 07/02/2012
Posts:

There are no orders as for considering LDCE on par with Direct recruitment. AS for now you got 3 promotions and hence not eligible for MACP.

Guest's picture
Sanjay kanchan

R/Sir
I was appointed as ASM on 23-12-98  in4500-7000 grade. I was promoted in 5000-8000 grade on feb 2002.
I came mutual transfer from sambalpur division to Jhansi division in June 2008. My seniority fix on 13-07-2001  grade 4500-7000 in Jhansi division.
I have not recieved MACP benefit. Please tell me when i got MACP benefit. Sanjay kanchan

Guest's picture
Guest

Sir, I hv joined railway in grade 2550-55-3200  in 5/6/1996 . 
I was promoted in grade 2650-65-4000  in 1999
i got another promotion as ASM through GDCE quota in grade 4500-7000  in  year  2000
I got promotion in grade 5000-8000 in  year 2002
 i got  5000-8000 in 6 and half year service.
Now i wnt to know , When i would get MACP and how many due for me, Please reply me soon
 
Sir coz in nov 2012 my ten years in 4200 will be completed.,
 HOW many MACP Due  for me 
One reply i hv received and according to that i vll get MACP in NOV .But   Some body  told me that u hv got  three promotions already so  no MACP will be given to me in future
please give me detail that how many MACP due for me , please reply

Guest's picture
jose

There are no orders as for considering LDCE on par with Direct recruitment. As for now you got 3 promotions and you are not eligible for MACP.

Guest's picture
Sanjay kanchan

R/Sir
I was appointed as ASM on 23-12-98  in4500-7000 grade. I was promoted in 5000-8000 grade on feb 2002.
I came mutual transfer from sambalpur division to Jhansi division in June 2008. My seniority fix on 13-07-2001  grade 4500-7000 in Jhansi division.
I have not recieved MACP benefit. Please tell me when i got MACP benefit. Sanjay kanchan

fs's picture
fs
Offline
Joined: 04/04/2012
Posts:

First MACP is not given in case of one way transfer. You will get second MACP in 2018 or 10 years from getting 4200 in new division which is earlier.

Guest's picture
GUEST

sir,

The teachers of NF Railway schools are confused whether they are eligible or not for MACP.Till date none of the teachers given the benefits of MACP.

Guest's picture
Guest

Sir I have joined Railway in 1986 as Jr Clerk

I have get promotion of Sr.Clerk in 1989

Next Hd. Ckerk promotion I have got in Nov 03

When my next promotion was due

Guest's picture
Guest

I am selected as senior section engineer track machine...whta will be the next promotion & after how many days.......

jp's picture
jp
Offline
Joined: 07/02/2012
Posts:

Next promotion is AEN(Gaz). You have to write Promotional exam for this. How many years depends on your hardwork for the exam and service record. It can be 5-15 years.

Guest's picture
Maneesh Kumar

I have join railway on 27-05-2008 as ALP Firozpur Division Northern Railway in 2012 I have selected as JE by RRB Mumbai and appointment given in POH Bhusaval before this I have taken NOC from my divisional HQ by competiting authority Sr DME and through proper channel I have relieved on 30-05-2012 and I have join in POH on 11-06-2012 (on this my basic pay was 9220 and GP 2400). I want to know my payment structure because in POH they are giving me only stipend of trainee JE. Weather I eligible for TA and the payment of ALP OR payment of JE. Am I eligible for bonus for this year
Please tell me the payment structure as trainee JE

SPP's picture
SPP
Offline
Joined: 14/07/2012
Posts:

You have to be given payment of ALP and TA. You are eligible for bonus.

Guest's picture
Maneesh Kumar

Sir
How much should I eligible and any circulars regarding this matter because ELW bhusaval officers told me that you are eligible for stipend only. I told them that I am railway employee and I will get all benefits but they did not agree with me.

Guest's picture
Maneesh Kumar

SPP Sir
Please send me any circulars regarding this matter because ELW Bhusaval are not agree to me the payment as employees. They are giving me only stipend of trainee JE

Guest's picture
Guest N.K Mishra

Sir, 

I got promotion as Loco Pilot (Goods) in march 2000 in Gr PAY 4200. After ten years I got benefit under MACP  My Gr Pay became 4600. But it is learnt that my Gr pay is going to reduce as there is no Gr pay 4600 in this cader . In promotion from Loco Pilot (Goods) to Loco Pilot (P) benefits given is Gr Pay 4600+500 Additional Allowance. So Please enable me what benefit I will get as a benifit of MACP  or my current Gr Pay 4600 is correct. 

SPP's picture
SPP
Offline
Joined: 14/07/2012
Posts:

MACP higher GP is given irrespective of whether it is available in your cadre or not.

Guest's picture
Maneesh Kumar

Sir
I have selected as JE by RRB Mumbai. I want to know the payment as trainee JE (elect) because I was working as ALP(basic pay 9220 and GP 2400) from 27-05-2008 to 30-05-2012 I relieved from ALP through proper channel after taking NOC from my divisional HQ by competiting authority Sr DME. Please tell me how much payment, TA ,HRA.BONUS, INCREMENTS(increment date 01-07-2012) have to given to me.

Guest's picture
Maneesh Kumar

Jp sir please tell me the payment structure of trainee JE before this I was working as ALP from 27-05-2008 to 30-05-2012 and I was relieved through proper channel with NOC sir how much payment TA HRA.BONUS INCREMENTS (due on 01-07-2012) should given to me. Because I am getting only stipend of trainee JE (22200 only)

To protect against spam we limit the Comments only for the registerd users. Please register  or loginThank you for your understanding.

Custom Search